judge mccarthy broward. Mitch Baxter, et al Defendant, CACE08006807 in Florida State, Broward County, Seventeenth Circuit Court, Barbara 03 McCarthy presiding, last filing 08/26/2008, filed 02/15/2008. judge mccarthy broward

 
 Mitch Baxter, et al Defendant, CACE08006807 in Florida State, Broward County, Seventeenth Circuit Court, Barbara 03 McCarthy presiding, last filing 08/26/2008, filed 02/15/2008judge mccarthy broward com

215(b)(3). New report details government's efforts to prosecute human trafficking 06:30. Charlie Crist (R) in January 2009, to replace the late Judge Charles Kaplan. Law. Broward Circuit Judge Elizabeth Scherer imposed the statutorily mandated sentence Wednesday, ordering Nikolas Cruz, 24, to serve a life sentence with no possibility of parole for each of the 17. Hon DePrimo, Natasha. OF MAGISTRATE JUDGE JUDGE BARBARA : McCARTHY, ET. JQ/34 Jose Izquierdo JS/39 Hope Tieman Bristol JT/46 Yael Gamm JU Kenneth Gillespie (C)Domestic Violence Judges Division Judge FV/57 Peter Holden 59/57 Michael G. Date: August 31, 2020. Catalina Avalos, of Pembroke Pines, to serve as Judge on the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit Court Avalos has served as a County Court Judge for Broward County since 2022. She was appointed to the bench by former Governor Jerry Brown on November 2, 2017, filling a vacancy created by the retirement of the Hon. Q: How late is the courthouse open? A: The courthouse hours are 8am – 5pm, Monday through Friday. Charlie Greene retired as a Circuit Judge after more than 32 years on the bench. Karen F. Rodriguez v. To get started and understand how the forms work, Read the BASIC INSTRUCTIONS. Saint Anthony Catholic School is the parochial Catholic school of St. Hon Harper, Bradley. Judge Michael Rudisill Division “G” Civil/Family Case Manager – 407-665-4263 or email: [email protected]. The best top ranked private high schools in Broward County, FL include Westminster Academy, AEF Schools and The American Academy, Broward Campus. McKee - internet-based Clerk: Dolores McBean 212-240-4925;. But he refuses to allow the judge. com. 57/MV Kathleen McCarthy 63 Stefanie C. State judges. McCarthy doesn't have votes to advance Biden impeachment inquiry, reports say 11 Sept 2023 Republican senator says top federal officials should disclose medical recordsThe self-help website includes family law forms approved by the Florida Supreme Court. Judges with the Highest Case Loads in Broward County. Hon DePrimo, Natasha. Byatt (1936–2023), bestselling author of Possession. D. COCE Judges Pre-Jgmt Writ of Attachment + Pre-Jgmt Writ of Garn + Prejgmt Writ of Attachment $100 - $2500 Prejgmt Writ/Garn $100 - $2500 Prior Disposed Case - CV + Product Liability/Del-MonteJose Alejandro Gonzalez Jr. Pursuant to rule 2. Get started . Skip to main content. ANTHONY (2011) Casey Anthony is on trial for the 2008 murder of her 2-year-old daughter, Caylee. Iqbal, 556 U. Kevin J. Panelists Meet at the 17th Circuit. The court schedule is provided as a public service only. The United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida has jurisdiction in Broward County. Goerner. Home; Contact Us; Toggle Navigation. Hon. Office of the Chief Judge; Divisions of the Court; Judiciary; Judiciary List by Division; Judiciary Assignment chart; General Magistrates & Hearing Officers; County to Circuit Appellate Panel; Court Administration. Lauderdale, Fla. 17th Circuit Closed in Observance of Veterans Day. Broward County Circuit Court Directory 201 SE 6th St. The Judge overseeing this case is McCarthy, Kathleen. Judge Holden is the main antagonist of the late Cormac McCarthy's 1985 anti-Western epic novel Blood Meridian. org: Y: Sara Alijewicz (561) 996-4841 : Isabel Pereira : Z: Sarah Willis (561) 355-7847Broward County (/ ˈ b r aʊ. 10 of the Most Memorable Quotes from Blood Meridian. 215, and section 102. The school is recognized as a Catholic Education Honor Roll. He is a past president of the Broward County Hispanic Bar Association (2007-2008). Former field artillery officer, United States Army, Active duty, 1989-1992; Reserve, 1992-2003. Prior to joining the bench, he worked for five years as a capital. +1 (954) 831-3580. 2023 DAILY BUSINESS REVIEW BROWARD U. Our forty-eight acre campus provides a safe and structured environment for our students with an emphasis on faith, family and education. JUDGE McCARTHY, et al. S. S. m. CHIEF Judge Jack Tutor knows – many ederly targeted – RIGGED DEFSULT. MCCARTHY BARBARA: Lakisha Holmes (954) 831-7208: FI: 712-207-714: MCCARTHY KATHLEEN:. We are lucky to have him. The trial judge’s consideration of the receiver amount ed to a Meeting ID: 930 3054 1310. South Palm Beach County Bar Association Jurist of the Year (1999) Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, Mentor Coordinator (for new Judges) Associate Judge, Florida Fourth District Court of Appeals. Broward County Court July 28, 2008 Judge Reinaldo Ojeda Polk County Court August 12, 2008 Judge Archie Hayward, Jr. EMERGENCY JUDGES: Listing of emergency judges on duty at night and on weekends in civil, probate, criminal, juvenile circuit and county courts. Hernandez, Hugo. Most likely the. The event featured 14 judges and 2 magistrates serving the 17th Judicial Circuit. 215(b)(3). Topic. Eligible to Practice Law in Florida. But recently Destry has come under scrutiny for sentencing a 23-year-old to 60 years in prison for a nonviolent probation violation and then, after a viral online petition, changing the sentence to just probation . Division Procedures. Gillespie (Judge) Hon. Mairale Dyson (954) 831-7258. State of Florida*. Bailey's reversals topped the tallies for Broward Senior Judge Joel T. Moon (D)Family Judges Division Judge Barbara Anne McCarthy. Sen. Mitch Baxter, et al Defendant, CACE08006807 in Florida State, Broward County, Seventeenth Circuit Court, Barbara 03 McCarthy presiding, last filing 08/26/2008, filed 02/15/2008. Judicial Complex. Dudek on 2023-11-21. at Boston College Law School in 1987. Judge Barbara McCarthy Seventeenth Circuit January 28, 2009 Judge Carlos Rodriguez Seventeenth Circuit January 28, 2009 Judge Dawn Caloca-Johnson. Broward County Circuit Court Directory 201 SE 6th St. Constantly updated. As of November 2023, the total number of DeSantis appointees was 104. 6th Street #147. McCarthy - internet-based Clerk: Yariselle Alvarado 212-240-4971; James R. 662, 129 S. Summaries of. Watch the 5. S. . Marc H. Kevin M. She was elected to a full six-year term in 2010. m. Jud. Filing# 153917914 E-Filed 07/22/2022 07:28:12 PM IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 17thJUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA BROWARD ICW INVESTMENTS, LLC a Florida limited liabilitycompany, CASENO: CACE-22-008591 (09) Plaintiff. @2017 10th Judicial Circuit of Florida. Court FAQs; Service of Electronic Orders; Traffic Program – FAQ; Family. Judicial Assistant Vikki Cooper. Taking inspiration from the real-life Glanton Gang, a group of scalp hunters that operated in the US-Mexico Borderlands during the 1840s, McCarthy sculpted a wonderfully intricate and disturbing world for his characters to breathe in. Chamber WW-15131. Follow this link to skip to the main content. McCarthy, who grew up in Long Island and went to college in Massachusetts, spent nearly eight years as a special education teacher before going to law school at St. Former Governor Jeb Bush appointed Judge Rodriguez Powell to the Circuit Court in 2005. Ireland, who each had 12. West Regional Courthouse. Ketchel Judge W. Cruz was. K. From 2001 to . m. IMPORTANT COURT INFORMATION: TO ALL PARTIES: PLEASE DO NOT E-MAIL THE JUDGE DIRECTLY ON ANY CASE(S), INSTEAD, PLEASE CONTACT CHAMBERS. AND HEARING OFFICERS (a) Florida Rule of Judicial Administration 2. Trialnet. Mason Elrod, West Broward, baseball: Elrod went 3 for 4 with two home runs and five RBI to lead the Bobcats to a 10-9 walk-off win over Taravella. The Florida man who claimed his girlfriend choked to death during oral sex was found not guilty of second-degree murder Monday. On 01/27/2016 Robert J Coy Petitioner filed a Family - Marriage Dissolution/Divorce lawsuit against Diane Coy Respondent. Welcome to our Judicial Directory. Judicial Complex North Regional Courthouse West Regional Courthouse South Regional Courthouse ———————————— The good judge has a spotless record of many years as an attorney and 14 plus spotless years as a judge. All Year Cooling & Heating Inc, et al Defendant, CACE10048403 in Florida State, Broward County, Seventeenth Circuit Court, Barbara McCarthy presiding, last filing 02/02/2012, filed 12/23/2010. The first expansion to the existing courthouse took place in 1991 and the courthouse was officially renamed the Marion County Judicial Center. 13. from Indiana State University in 1968. DISTRICT 23-cv-81487-DMM, Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America v. The event featured 14 judges and 2 magistrates serving the 17th Judicial Circuit. Probate, Family Law and all other divisions. T. - 4 p. , Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301 Circuit Court, Seventeenth Judicial Circuit Judicial Circuit Judge Judicial Assistant Phone Number Chamber JACK TUTER Maria E. Kenneth L. Ed. A. Lucy Ramos Miller (General Magistrate) Hon. Division Judge 47 48 Kathleen McCarthy Jennifer Wigand Hilal 49 Nina. Broward County Bar Association: Bench and Bar Committee since 1998; Judicial Survey since 1999; Peer Review Council since 2004; Inns of Court Foundation – Stephen R. Until all of the Divisions are on aiCalendar, please check both online systems for the selected Division. GENERAL PROCEDURES FOR DIVISION 47. During her time on the bench, she has held assignments in the Civil and Probate Divisions. The Hon. Like the circuit courts, the Florida County Court selects its judges through nonpartisan elections. Retired Judge Barbara McCarthy Barbara McCarthy has presided over thousands of lawsuits, ranging from discovery disputes to complex multi-party civil matters, as well as over 750 jury trials, and also served as a Civil Magistrate for over seven (7) years in Broward County. Case Management; Court Interpreters; Court Reporting; Drug Court; Foreclosure Program; General. in the jurisdiction of Broward County, FL. Leading personal injury law firm with over $1 Billion won for our clients. E. S. Broward County Courthouse 201 S E 6th Street Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301. Gary Farmer, a state senator, won against Tania Maria Williams, a lawyer and hearing officer for the Palm Beach County school district, to replace the retiring Broward Circuit Judge Barbara McCarthy. Goodman Judge Michael Jones Judge Terrance R. +1 (954) 831-3580. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Under no circumstances are minor children to be brought into the courtroom. She also worked as a prosecutor with the Broward state attorney’s office and a 4th District Court of Appeal clerk for then Judge Barry Stone. PINE ISLAND ROAD, ROOM 210. Filed. Court FAQs; Service of Electronic Orders; Traffic Program – FAQ; Family. 2022-2-Gen ASSIGNING JUDGES, GENERAL MAGISTRATES AND HEARING OFFICERS (a) Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2. JUDICIAL ASSISTANT Eva-Tanja Cuthbert. Self Help Center. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It is only known that the Judge is active around the. 32940 (321) 617-7310 tabrown@sa18. “I know this is a David and Goliath situation,” said McCarthy, alluding to Zaccor’s strong. Updated: 12/20/2013 . Especially not w those who query the above search terms and come across this post. C. McCarthy for hearing and disposition of all non-dispositive motions or applications, supervision of discovery, and to hear and report upon dispositive motions for consideration by the district judge. A. Beginning in 1950, McCarthy became the most visible public face of a period in the United States in which Cold War tensions fueled fears of widespread. Mar 24, 2023. government. Judges with the Highest Case Loads in Broward County. Gary Farmer, who was the Senate Democratic Leader until last April, has filed to run for an open judge position in the 17th Circuit Court in Broward County, the state elections site shows. It’s a demand, not a request, to witness the coming horror with the child at. McCarthy went on to be elected to the House in 2007 to fill the seat left vacant when Thomas, his old boss, retired. , and Paul Ryan, R-Wis. The school building was built in 1926 by. Chamber Orange County Courthouse. He then served as a Felony Division Chief, then as Chief Assistant over Manatee County and then Chief Assistant over all 3 counties in the 12 th circuit. Judge Benson Honored by Broward County. DO NOT EMAIL CHAMBERS UNLESS SPECIFICALLY INSTRUCTED TO DO SO. from Florida Atlantic University and a J. ) Honors Speech & Debate; Jobs For Florida (JFG) ProgramJudith C. West Broward High Western High Whiddon Rogers High *Inactive. JACS Court Scheduling - menu. 17th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida. (305) 349-7044. 17th District Court Mission Statement. m & 1:00 p. Lucy Ramos Miller (General Magistrate) Broward Circuit Judge Barbara McCarthy was shredded by the media and legal circles in early June when she sentence Ryan LeVin, 36, to two years of house arrest in his parents oceanfront condo. Offices in Broward, Jacksonville, Miami, N. Richard Patterson, 65, of Margate, was acquitted of killing 60-year-o…St. org. It was February 1950 when Joseph McCarthy, the Republican Senator from Wisconsin, brandished a list of 205 suspected Communists he said were working for the US State Department. We pledge equality and fairness to all. Thomas. 3. Material design admin template with pre-built apps and pagesBroward County Court Directory 201 SE 6th St. John J. Material design admin template with pre-built apps and pagesBroward County Sites; Courthouse Law Library; eFiling Portal Instructions; Florida Sites; Florida Judicial Sites; Florida Law Schools; Florida Legislature Sites; Florida Legal Organizations; Federal Sites; Guides to Law on the Web; Employment Opportunities; FAQ’s. orgCollier. Keyword Research: People who searched broward county judge barbara mccarthy also searchedThe Judges of the Ninth Judicial Circuit have developed numerous court programs and services to help facilitate the judicial process and to better serve the people of Orange and Osceola Counties. He was appointed to the bench by former Governor Ed Rendell on June 18, 2007. Read about great schools like: AEF Schools, The American Academy, Broward Campus and American Heritage Schools, Broward Campus. 73 West Flagler ST Miami, FL 33130. S. S. Date: August 31, 2020. +1 (954) 831-3580. Arbitrator/Mediator for American Arbitration Association and. Biography. 201 S. Pretrial Conferences are held on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays @ 9:00 a. Judicial Complex. Apr 20, 1995. 13 Responses to “Broward: More Than A Dozen Judges Are Related” Dean says: February 10th, 2014 at 10:38 am. She was elected to the bench in 2000 and re-elected in 2006, 2012, and 2018. Previously, she was a Director at Tripp Scott P. 6th Street, Ft. Not required if the decedent has been dead for more than 2 years. Based on historical events that took place on the Texas-Mexico border in the 1850s, it traces the fortunes of the Kid, a. Courtroom Deputy Clerk: Eric Glynn (716) 551-1881. Additional resources include a directory of local self-help centers, web links to free and low cost legal aid, mediator search capabilities, and guardianship resources. Lee 54 Florence Taylor. (Judge) Hon. Judge Judicial Assistant. Sub Division 22, Division E. N. Lee County Court August 12, 2008101-200 (out of 10000) court records for Broward County Circuit Court, FL. Hon Garcia-Wood, Marina. J. with the judges of the Fourth District Court of Appeal and the Chief Judges of our circuits. Public. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 407-422-4537. PRAECIPE FILED INSTRUCTIONS FOR. He is inspired by the allegedly real-life purported scalp hunter of the same name. E. There wasn’t much Kelly Garrick could say before Broward Circuit Judge sentenced her to 12 years in prison Thursday. S. The Seventeenth Judicial Circuit of Florida created specialized criminal and civil domestic violence divisions, comprised of four judges and support services to deal exclusively. S. To receive eservice and ability to upload documents, users need to be registered with the state E-portal. 33301. Kathleen M. _____/ I. fm. On September 10, 2020, Broward County Bar Association Hispanic Lawyer Committee, Broward County Hispanic Bar and Broward County Latin Entrepreneurs hosted our 2nd Annual Behind the Gavel: A Celebration of Broward Hispanic Judges. ” He’s facing two misdemeanor trespass and two felony conspiracy charges. Name: Initials: Status: Chambers: Appt. Douglas, a partner at Harper Grey LLP, is appointed a judge of the Supreme Court of British Columbia. The 17th Judicial Directory contains Broward County Judge’s telephone numbers and more. Office: 954-249-9118. 100; Civil Action No l:10-cv. The Hon. Find latests mugshots and bookings from Cape Coral and other local cities. Athens County Courthouse, 1 S. The application of the Twombly standard was clarified in Ashcroft v. She gave 22 recognizance bonds — including two charged with felony robbery. and Szorosy, Annette J. 14. Glenn Kelley, Chief Judge Kimberly Wolf, Judicial Assistant (561) 355-7814. 17th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida. *** CLICK HERE TO PURCHASE CLE CODE Last year, he was tied with Broward Judge Barbara McCarthy for having the most sentences he dished out overturned on appeal — at 11. Court FAQs; Service of Electronic Orders; Traffic Program – FAQ; Family. He had fatally struck the tourists and fled in his Porsche. Is Located at 201 SE 6th Street, Ft Lauderdale, Fl. John J. Nothing in Judge McCarthy’s Individual Practices supersedes a specific time. Moon 4 Effective March 1, 2022 . The Circuit Criminal Division hears major criminal (felony) cases where the resulting penalty can be imprisonment in a state penitentiary or death. He won in the general election on November 7, 2023. The Fourth District Court of Appeal held an induction ceremony for the swearing in of new Florida attorneys on Wednesday, October 4, 2023, at 11:00 a. 12. Welty in 2019. org: Circuit Criminal Division Judge Phone Judicial Assistant Email; R: Caroline Shepherd. Broward County Sites; Courthouse Law Library; eFiling Portal Instructions; Florida Sites; Florida Judicial Sites; Florida Law Schools; Florida Legislature Sites;. General Information Main Line: (954) 831-6077. Lynn Rosenthal was sworn in as a 17th Judicial Circuit judge on August 1, 2012. Amendment 4 and 14 illegal government seizures of homestead The right to known – Color of Law title 18 sec 242, 241. Archbishop Mccarthy High Blanche Ely High Cardinal Gibbons High Chaminade-Madonna Prep. E. Before becoming a certified mediator, Barbara presided over thousands of lawsuits, ranging from discovery disputes to complex multi-party civil matters, as well as over 750 jury trials. officer tried to saved Tessier's life and EMS took over just before 5:15 a. Page 4 of 6. S. The court has barred comments from previous co-defendants, other activists involved not charged and DxE animal rescuers. If you are a citizen. 60 minute hearings may be scheduled with Division’s approval on selective motions). Barbara Anne McCarthy (Judge) Hon. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Further, in order to schedule a case. American anti-communist propaganda of the 1950s, specifically addressing the entertainment industry. Date Filed Document Text; December 29, 2021: Filing 2089 COMPLAINT Vera R. 17th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida. In order to achieve our mission we shall utilize all available resources and technology. Broward Transitional Center Hearing Location. Maura K. N. Steve W. WHITE. HOW TO USE THE INFORMATION IN THIS SECTION: If you have questions about this section or the data listed here or need to publish a public notice in the Daily Business Review, call: 305. By Judge. in political science from the University of California. +1 (954) 831-7608. Murphy III, each with 13; and Palm Beach Senior Judge Howard H. , Deerfield. Dial in: (877-853-5257 - 888-475-4499) ALL UMC HEARINGS ARE TO BE SCHEDULED THROUGH THE 15th JUDICIAL CIRCUIT'S ONLINE SCHEDULING SYSTEM THROUGH ONLINE SERVICES and conducted via ZOOM - PLEASE READ BELOW FOR FURTHER INFORMATION:The north wing of the Broward County Judicial Complex is now known as the Judge Thomas J. No judgment may seem like a surprising thing for Broward County Judge Florence Taylor Barner to say about her hearings. , Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301 Circuit Court, Seventeenth Judicial Circuit. Petersburg, Tampa, West Palm Beach, and a Mobile Law Office, there's an office nearby no matter where you live or work. Judge McCarthy also has prohibited evidence from an investigation and rescue at McCoy’s Poultry, and a Sonoma County Animal Services’ report that corroborates the. 610 Opperman Drive. Select Month Below:Local Rules. referred to United States Magistrate Judge Jeremiah J. Durand Adams 1984 - 2008 (Circuit) Robert Bennett 1992 - 2010 (Circuit) Robert Blue 1986 - 1992 (Circuit) 1992 - 2003 (DCA) Kimberly Bonner 2002 - 2022 (Circuit) Robert Boylston 1985 - 1997 (Circuit) Barbara Briggs 1992 - 2010 (Circuit)A. COCE Judges Pre-Jgmt Writ of Attachment + Pre-Jgmt Writ of Garn + Prejgmt Writ of Attachment $100 - $2500 Prejgmt Writ/Garn $100 - $2500 Prior Disposed Case - CV + Product Liability/Del-MonteKathleen McCarthy candidate for Broward County Court Judge Group 8 speaking at Emerge USA forum in Sunrise, Florida. The case status is Disposed - Dismissed. From the very first lines of the novel, McCarthy calls upon us to regard unflinchingly the dark tale that’s about to be told: “See the child. The plaintiff has not alleged any facts that demonstrate that Judge Barbara McCarthy acted in the absence of jurisdiction. 19,039,971. By using this system you consent to the. Miami, Orlando, St. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Elected in 2020. 00 debt. & also serves as Division Judge in the Complex Business Division 07. The Florida Seventeenth Circuit Court is one of twenty circuit courts in Florida. Nothing in Judge McCarthy’s Individual Practices supersedes a specific time. Stacy: FC 02: CHC 2128: 305-349-6110: Rodriguez-Fonts, Oscar: FC 07: CHC 2926: 305-349-5681 ; MINOR CHILDREN-Please make arrangements Not to bring children. DeSantis Appoints 2 Judges to Broward Circuit Court Bench “I’ve always had a passion for public service and it was unfinished business,” Judge Catalina Avalos said Monday about her. To use this program, a case must be filed in Broward County and a family mediation order must be signed by a Broward judge. A Broward Circuit judge has been removed from a case after an appeals court found the judge acted in a threatening manner. Gary Farmer, who was the Senate Democratic Leader until last April, has filed to run for an open judge position in the 17th Circuit Court in Broward County, the state elections site shows. National Surface Cleaning, No. Attorney Ori Feistmann Silver, who is an assistant state attorney in Broward County, is among six lawyers who have been nominated to replace Harper, who in September was elevated to the circuit. "T. Scott, while confined at Broward County Jail, has filed a pro se civil rights complaint pursuant to 42 U. Case docket: Deutsche Bank Nat Tr Co Plaintiff vs. Levenson and retired Broward Judge Kathleen D. I’m not sure that will go over well w Broward voters. The Fifteenth Judicial Circuit is a general jurisdiction court with 35 circuit judges presiding. Mail Address: PO Box 460536. 26, Florida Statutes, Florida Rule of Judicial Administration 2. , 1:13-cv-00892, W. ) was a judge for the Pierce County Superior Court in Washington. Broward County State Attorney's Office & Florida Bar The plaintiff appears to be suing the Broward County State Attorney's Office and the Florida Bar because he is unhappy with his gun-related charges filed against him in. Senior Judge: 1700 Frick Building: 412. The Judges overseeing this case are Bailey, Dennis D. 2, 2022. A Wisconsin attorney, McCarthy served for three years as a circuit judge (1940–42) before enlisting in the U. The 17th Judicial Circuit serves the citizens of Broward County Florida. Chief Judge. Otherwise, t he practices of the District Judge to whom the case is assigned apply. Anthony Catholic Church in Broward County. WHITETrellis. Judge George P. Hon. On March 04, 2020, Strouse, Judith et al. During her first session, McCarthy set bail for 27 defendants. Fourth DCA Reversals of Judge Barbara McCarthy. 4D12-4282, 4D12-4283 and 4D12-4284-Royce Goldsmith v.